← All writing
Nov 18, 2026

The Pricing Trap: Why Most Makers Undercharge (and How to Fix It)

Undercharging isn't a math problem — it's a habit problem. Here's a practical way to reprice your work without guessing.

I've talked to dozens of makers about pricing, and the conversation almost always goes the same way. They tell me their price. I ask how they arrived at it. They say something like "I looked at what other people charge" or "I wanted to keep it affordable" or "I tried to calculate materials plus a bit." Almost none of them mention their own time.

This is the trap. Undercharging is rarely a math error — it's a habit of undervaluing the work, and it's reinforced by a marketplace that rewards cheap prices and a culture that treats craft as a hobby rather than a business.

Let's fix it.

Start with a real hourly rate — and don't flinch.

Most makers I know set their hourly rate at $15 or $20 because it feels "reasonable." But reasonable compared to what? If you're running a business, your hourly rate needs to cover not just your time at the bench but also the hours you spend on admin, photography, customer service, and packaging. I use a simple rule: set your rate at what you'd need to pay someone else to do the work reliably. For most skilled craft work, that's $25–$40 an hour. If that sounds high, consider that a plumber charges $75+ and no one blinks.

Track time for one batch, not every batch.

You don't need to time yourself every day. Pick one representative batch — say, a run of 12 candles — and time every step: setup, pouring, cleanup, labeling, photographing, listing. Most makers are shocked by the admin time. When I did this for my mugs, I found that a "20-minute mug" actually took 75 minutes from start to listed. That changes the math.

Separate materials from overhead.

Materials are easy: wax, wick, tin, label. Overhead is everything else: your kiln's electricity, your Notion subscription, your Etsy fees, your packaging supplies, the gas to drive to the post office. Most makers forget overhead entirely. I add a flat 15% overhead to every product's cost. It's not perfect, but it's better than zero.

Price for the customer you want, not the one you're afraid of.

This one is hard. If you price low to attract budget customers, you'll get more of them — and they'll be the ones who ask for discounts and complain about lead times. If you price fairly and explain your process, you'll attract customers who value the work. I raised my mug prices by 40% last year and lost exactly two customers. I gained better margins and fewer headaches.

Use a calculator, not a gut feeling.

My pricing calculator template does three things: it takes your materials cost, adds overhead, multiplies by your hourly rate times the time per unit, and then shows you the wholesale and retail price with a target margin. The formula is simple: (materials + overhead + labor) ÷ (1 - target margin). If you want a 60% margin, you divide by 0.4. Most makers are shocked at how high that number is — but that's what it actually costs to run a business.

Test one product at a time.

Don't reprice your whole shop overnight. Pick your best-selling product, reprice it using the calculator, and watch what happens for a month. If sales hold steady, you've just given yourself a raise. If they drop, you'll know quickly. Either way, you'll have data instead of fear.

Keep a record of every quote.

Custom orders are where pricing gets fuzzy. I keep a simple log in Notion: product, customer, quoted price, actual time, and whether I'd quote it the same way again. After a year, I had enough data to see that I was consistently underestimating custom work by about 30%. Now I add a custom surcharge without apology.

The mindset shift matters more than the math.

At some point, you have to decide that your work is worth paying for. Not because it's precious, but because you're running a business and businesses need to cover their costs. The math is the easy part. The hard part is believing it.

If you're stuck, start with one product and one honest hour of time tracking. You don't need a perfect system. You need a starting point. The pricing calculator template is that starting point, but even a notebook will do — as long as you stop guessing.